New Jersey Stage logo
New Jersey Stage Menu



 

Sawyer Conlon: "Overbrook"


By Tris McCall, Eye Level

originally published: 03/12/2025

Dead leaves and the dirty ground: Sawyer Conlon rocks

The very moment you step into the gallery, Sawyer Conlon hits you with a picture of a tombstone. He's fixed photographs of bare trees, each one with branches greyed by mist and suitable to star on the cover of a Norwegian black metal album, to the walls. Power lines subdivide grey skies, and scrub reed struggles up from the frosty ground. If that's not creepy enough, there's the soundtrack — warbly old music from the pre-jazz era, fitting for Jack Torrance at that Overlook Hotel party in 1921.

You’re thinking: I know what this is. It’s a horror show.

And you’d be right, sort of. “Overbrook” at SMUSH Gallery (340 Summit Ave.) does draw from the stylistic conventions of spooky cinema. But it’s much more indebted to Weird Jersey-ana: the creeping sense that there’s a strange and secret Underjersey tucked between the green aisles of the suburban towns. This combination of literature and guerrilla photography is calibrated to channel the Garden State uncanny.

Conlon’s narrative installation is set at the Overbrook Asylum, an infamous psychiatric hospital complex in bucolic Cedar Grove that was mostly shut down in the late 20th century and has been a magnet for ghost-dodging trespassers ever since. “Overbrook” is not an urban exploration exhibition: Conlon did not shimmy his way into the asylum and take shots of crumbling walls and medical residue. He’s an investigator nonetheless. Escape, for his main character, may be figurative rather than physical. He’s heading straight into the psychic abyss, but he’s doing it with his sense of wonder, and terror, intact.

Messages from the (inner) void: Sawyer Conlon's "12-16-1916"

Weird NJ devotees and Essex County ghost-watchers know, or believe they know, four things about Overbrook. This stark, engrossing little show, which will only hang at SMUSH until the 16th of the month, alludes to them all. First, the asylum was sprawling. A visitor could easily lose herself in its haunted halls. Second, in further overtones of The Shining, it was so cold in the rooms that patients actually froze to death. Third, the hospital was in the suburbs, right where the radios towers and brick buildings meet the first line of dense and spectral Jersey forest. Fourth (and this can’t be proven, but many people are sure it’s true) is that Overbrook is still home to phantoms — the specters of the thousands who died there — and if you’re nearby and you’ve got your antenna out, you’re liable to pick up some freaky transmissions.




Promote your shows at New Jersey Stage! Click here for info



Conlon believes it, or wants to believe it, and he keeps his aerial aloft as he journeys around the woods with his camera. He’s hoping to catch something numinous, and in many of these pictures, he does. He’s not afraid to literalize the chase for spiritual inspiration, in the remarkable “01-19-1917,” he outlines a baroque city clock in white, and connects its spire to the top of the print. Has it been struck by lightning, or is it transmitting etheric fire? Either way, this symbol of official record-keeping and supervision is alive and vibrant in a way that the winter trees are not. The photographer didn’t have to reverse the image to make his point. We all know that in psychological thrillers, the clocks run backwards, and in “Overbrook,” nothing is quite as ungovernable as time.

At the chime of a city clock: bare trees & the timepiece

The photographer does his best to tame it, or at least keep an eye on it. Every photo in this show is dated — generally in late autumn 1916 or the early days of 1917. That puts the point of narration disturbingly close to the period when neglected Overbrook patients caught their death by cold. A feeling of perpetual March hovers over the entire installation, and a snowy fog clouds windows, chokes the branches of trees, and blurs lines all over the show. Some of the pieces, like the shot of the imposing relay tower in “01-23-1917,” look damp with condensation.

Conlon’s habit of drawing shaky white lines on his greyscale images amplifies the sense of alterity. It often feels like he’s using his camera as an X-ray machine, exposing the skeletons of the objects he’s captured with diagnostic curiosity and more than a bit of fear. In “01-25-1917,” his lines guide the eye down a weathered corridor toward an aperture in the distance and a glimpse of a mist-smeared landscape. This is the way we’re headed: toward disintegration and the loss of our ego boundaries. We are caught and carried by the wind that takes us up and away and into a glowering sky.

Small cards posted in between the dates and shots add ominous flavor to the tale. So do pages from books and letters, all severely redacted in an effort to expose the story behind the story, or maybe just the deep structure that might be animating a mysterious world. The hand of an authority is suggested, but we never get to see the Overbrook doctors, or anything clinical at all.

Instead, Conlon keeps the focus on his main character. He invites us to sit at an old desk with an antique typewriter and peer at the contents in the drawers. We’re shown family pictures, keepsakes, handwritten letters; the residue of a life in progress. Should we turn to the left, we can leaf through a photo album. It all feels very natural: an ordinary station in the apartment of a troubled but ordinary person. But it’s so heavy with a feeling of absence that we find ourselves searching for clues. What, exactly, went on here? What pushed the occupant of this desk to Overbrook? Did he meet his doom there?

Paranoia... maybe.

Those who visited the ArtYard will be reminded of Lance Weiler’s “Where There’s Smoke,” a flame-touched installation that doubled as a domestic mystery. Weiler decorated the gallery with images of fires of unknown origins, gave visitors flashlights and headsets, and turned them loose on the reconstructed contents of his pyromaniac father’s closets. There were no definite answers in that show, either, but just as in “Overbrook,” the grim implications were unmistakable.

Though there are many galleries in Jersey City overseen by smart curators, it’s hard to imagine “Overbrook” happening anyplace but SMUSH. This intersection between guerrilla art, immersive installation, spooky images, and literature is exactly where this gallery lives — and it’s why it is one of the essential creative spaces in town. Gallerists Katelyn Halpern and Benedicto Figueroa have both mounted shows like that. Last year, Buttered Roll turned SMUSH into a Borges-inspired deconstruction of Simón Bolivar; the year before, Nocturnal Medicine converted the little room into an altar-choked temple to the earth in distress.




Promote your shows at New Jersey Stage! Click here for info



This is all intellectual stuff, but it’s also a hell of a lot of fun, and it’s amazing how many shapes this modest storefront on Summit Avenue has taken over the past few years. It’s been a staging ground for active historiography, a scene of interpersonal devastation, and a house of worship. For another week, it’ll be a conduit to a weird and chilly time and place in the history of New Jersey, an inhabitable photograph, and a tiny ballroom for dancing with ghosts. Then the wheel will spin, and they’ll switch it up again.

(Yes, you should go to SMUSH Gallery whenever you can. The programming can be freaky, but it’s never boring — not for a second. “Overbrook” will be viewable on Thursday and Friday at 6 p.m. and Saturday and Sunday at 3 p.m.  There’s a suggested donation of $10-$20, and you can think of it as your contribution to keeping this innovative space alive and telling stories.)




Tris McCall regularly writes about visual art (and other topics) for NJArts.net, Jersey City Times, and other independent publications. He's also written for the Newark Star-Ledger, Jersey Beat, the Jersey City Reporter, the Jersey Journal, the Jersey City Independent, Inside Jersey, and New Jersey dot com. He also writes about things that have no relevance to New Jersey. Not today, though.

Eye Level is an online journal dedicated to visual art in Jersey City, New Jersey. A new review will appear every Tuesday morning at 8 a.m., and there'll be intermittent commentaries posted to the site in between those reviews.

Eye Level is made possible by an Andy Warhol Arts Writers Grant.


FEATURED EVENTS

ART | COMEDY | DANCE | FILM | MUSIC | THEATRE | COMMUNITY

To narrow results by date range, categories,
or region of New Jersey
click here for our advanced search.


MAC

MAC Music Café

Sunday, March 16, 2025 @ 4:00pm
Middletown Arts Center
36 Church Street, Middletown, NJ 07748




 

Purlie

Purlie

Sunday, March 16, 2025 @ 2:00pm
Hamilton Stage at Union County Performing Arts Center (UCPAC)
360 Hamilton Avenue, Rahway, NJ 07065



Andrew

Andrew Dice Clay

Sunday, March 16, 2025 @ 7:00pm
Bergen Performing Arts Center (bergenPAC)
30 North Van Brunt Street, Englewood, NJ 07631



Amadeus

Amadeus

Sunday, March 16, 2025 @ 2:00pm
Grunin Center - Black Box Theater
1 College Drive, Toms River, NJ 08754



Sesame

Sesame Street Live! Say Hello

Sunday, March 16, 2025 @ 2:00pm
State Theatre New Jersey
15 Livingston Avenue, New Brunswick, NJ 08901




 

EVENT PREVIEWS

Artworks

Artworks presents an Artist Talk with Clifford Ward

(TRENTON, NJ) -- Artworks presents an Artist Talk with Clifford Ward on Saturday, March 22, 2025 from 11:00am to 1:30pm. He will discusses his exhibition, I’ll Make Me A World. The event is free and open to the public.



Riverside

Riverside Gallery presents March Mosaic: A Celebration of Women's Art

(HACKENSACK, NJ) -- Riverside Gallery presents "March Mosaic," an inspiring exhibition presented by SALUTE To Women In The Arts in honor of Women’s History Month 2025. This vibrant showcase features the work of 38 talented women artists from northern New Jersey, celebrating their creativity, resilience, and artistic contributions.



Meet

Meet Photo Artist Nancy Gallagher at the Ocean County Library Long Beach Island Branch

(SURF CITY, NJ) -- The Ocean County Library Long Beach Island Branch is pleased to feature an exhibit of nature scenes captured by local photographer Nancy Gallagher. "Birds and More" will be on display in the Meeting Room throughout the month of April.



Clinton

Clinton to hold Art in Bloom Festival on April 6th

(CLINTON, NJ) -- The Art in Bloom Festival is returning to historic downtown Clinton on Sunday, April 6, 2025. After the overwhelming success of its inaugural year in 2024, the festival is set to bloom once again, showcasing the natural beauty of Clinton's cherry blossoms while celebrating local artisans, vibrant music, and the town's unique small-town charm.



Tanya

Tanya Weddemire Gallery presents CARVED IN COLOR BOUND BY LOVE

(BROOKLYN, NY) -- Tanya Weddemire Gallery is rooted into the ETHOS OF LOVE, exploring its powerful impact in our lives from the perspective of four prolific male artists in their next activation, CARVED IN COLOR BOUND BY LOVE Brooklyn, NY: March 13 through April 25, 2025.