New Jersey Stage logo
New Jersey Stage Menu



 

REVIEW: "Make Believe" at New Jersey Repertory

by Gary Wien
02/21/2025

Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill, photo by Andrea Phox

(LONG BRANCH, NJ) -- World premiere plays can be tricky.  Sometimes a few tweaks here and there can completely change a play for the better or for the worse, and I tend to give premieres a bit of leeway.  You're not just reviewing the play itself, but the play's potential as well.

New Jersey Repertory Company (NJ Rep) is currently presenting Make Believe by John Biguenet, a playwright who has had two previous works (Night Train and Broomstick) have their premieres at NJ Rep as well.

The production is directed by SuzAnne Barabas and stars Quentin Chisholm (Bailey) and Éilis Cahill (Eleanor) as two people in Hollywood during the 1930s. Bailey is a Hollywood star and Eleanor is a prostitute. They are meeting in a hotel room for the purpose of having the story of their affair caught by a photographer. It’s a PR stunt.

(Photos by NJ Rep)

Hollywood was the place of dreams and Bailey was not your ordinary heartthrob of the day.  He’s an actor who is gay decades before that was ok for a film star.  The problem is that there isn’t much mystery to it.  It’s fairly easy to see what the two are doing and why they are doing it.  In my opinion, not enough was done to provide a sense of him trying to hide his lifestyle or to show the Hollywood star in a different light. We wind up watching the two of them try to get their stories set rather than get inside their own lives more.

There are moments such as when Eleanor thought he looked a bit like the Hollywood star when she has him act out a scene from one of his films.  Moments like that offered an opportunity to create two distinct worlds for Bailey, but failed  to create the Hollywood image he was seeking to protect.





 

New Jersey Stage provides affordable advertising for the arts



I think the premise of the play is sound. Timing wise, it’s good to look back at the past and at a time when secrets like this could ruin an actor’s career - especially in light of the current political world which is pointing back to those days.  But for the play to truly work, we need Bailey to be an actor the audience could not imagine was gay - think of someone like Rock Hudson where the movie industry may have known, but the public was largely oblivious. That level of secret did not seem to be there for me.

Both Quentin Chisholm and Éilis Cahill do fine jobs with their roles, but it just seems like the play needs something more. Maybe it could benefit from Eleanor probing his lifestyle more or even threatening to blackmail him, but I think it really just needs a stronger contrast between Bailey the Hollywood star as the movie industry wants his persona to be seen and Bailey the man himself. The potential is there, but tweaks are needed.

The play runs through March 9, 2025 at New Jersey Repertory Company (179 Broadway) in Long Branch, New Jersey. For ticket information, click here.

This is one of nearly 130 world premieres to take place at NJ Rep since the company’s was founded in 1997 by SuzAnne and Gabor Barabas.  The company has done a remarkable job producing plays and giving playwrights opportunities. In addition to the full productions, the company has presented over 400 developmental readings and introduced more than 130 new works through its Theatre Brut Short-Play Festivals that focus on visionary and avant-garde works.

Here are more photos from the production by Andrea Phox.



Gary Wien has been covering the arts since 2001 and has had work published with Jersey Arts, Upstage Magazine, Elmore Magazine, Princeton Magazine, Backstreets and other publications. He is a three-time winner of the Asbury Music Award for Top Music Journalist and the author of Beyond the Palace (the first book on the history of rock and roll in Asbury Park) and Are You Listening? The Top 100 Albums of 2001-2010 by New Jersey Artists. In addition, he runs New Jersey Stage and the online radio station The Penguin Rocks. His personal website is at lightyscorner.com. He can be contacted at [email protected].




New Jersey Stage provides affordable advertising for the arts



About the author:

Gary Wien has been covering the arts since 2001 and has had work published with Jersey Arts, Upstage Magazine, Elmore Magazine, Princeton Magazine, Backstreets and other publications. He is a three-time winner of the Asbury Music Award for Top Music Journalist and the author of Beyond the Palace (the first book on the history of rock and roll in Asbury Park) and Are You Listening? The Top 100 Albums of 2001-2010 by New Jersey Artists. In addition, he runs New Jersey Stage and the online radio station The Penguin Rocks. His personal website is at lightyscorner.com. He can be contacted at [email protected].


 



Your shows can be listed here for just $10. Click here to learn more.

A

A Christmas Story: The Musical

Saturday, November 21, 2026 @ 2:00pm
State Theatre New Jersey
New Brunswick, NJ

“A JOYOUS CHRISTMAS MIRACLE!” –Associated Press



From the songwriting team behind the smash hit Tony® Award-winning musical Dear Evan Hansen and the critically-acclaimed films La La Land and The Greatest Showman, A Christmas Story: The Musical, brings the classic 1983 movie to hilarious life on stage! Set in 1940s Indiana, a young and bespectacled Ralphie Parker schemes his way toward the holiday gift of his dreams, an official Red Ryder® Carbine-Action 200-Shot Range Model Air Rifle. An infamous leg lamp, outrageous pink bunny pajamas, a maniacal department store Santa, and a triple-dog-dare to lick a freezing flagpole are just a few of the distractions that stand between Ralphie and his Christmas wish. Nominated for three 2013 Tony® Awards including Best Musical, the Associated Press calls A Christmas Story: The Musical, “a joyous Christmas miracle,” while The New York Times writes “I was dazzled. You’d have to have a Grinch-sized heart not to feel a smile spreading across your face.”

 

Kean

Kean Department of Theatre presents "The Drowsy Chaperone"

There are multiple performances including:

Saturday, November 21, 2026 @ 2:00pm

Kean Stage - Bauer Boucher Theatre Center
Union, NJ

Music and lyrics by Lisa Lambert and Greg Morrison

CLICK HERE to view all remaining performances.


OCVTS

OCVTS Grunin Performing Arts Academy presents "Present Laughter"

There are multiple performances including:

Saturday, November 21, 2026 @ 2:00pm

Grunin Center - Main Stage
Toms River, NJ

Step into the dazzling, chaotic world of Noël Coward’s Present Laughter—a sparkling, laugh-out-loud comedy about fame, love, and the art of always being on display.

CLICK HERE to view all remaining performances.


Tangled

Tangled Vows

There are multiple performances including:

Saturday, November 21, 2026 @ 3:00pm

Avenel Performing Arts Center
Avenel, NJ

Tangled Vows is a hilarious, heartfelt, way too relatable stage play about love, forgiveness, and what really happens after "I do."

CLICK HERE to view all remaining performances.


The

The Man Beneath the Mask

Sunday, November 22, 2026 @ 5:00pm
Avenel Performing Arts Center
Avenel, NJ

The Man Beneath the Mask is a powerful, relatable stage play about the hidden pressures men carry and the battles they fight in silence.

 

ADVANCED EVENTS

To search for a single date, choose the same starting and ending date.

Starting Date:
     

Ending Date:
     

 All Events   art   comedy 
 dance   film   kids 
 music   theatre   community 

 North Jersey 
 Central Jersey
 South Jersey


 


EVENT PREVIEWS

(AVENEL, NJ) -- Get ready for an exciting weekend of fun, laughter, drama, and live entertainment as Inspire 23 Productions presents two captivating stage plays (Tangled Vows and The Man Beneath the Mask) at the Avenel Performing Arts Center.



Art House Productions x Skyline Arts present "Ride the Cyclone The Musical: Teen Edition"

Art House Productions x Skyline Arts present "Ride the Cyclone The Musical: Teen Edition"

(JERSEY CITY, NJ) -- Art House Productions x Skyline Arts present Ride the Cyclone The Musical: Teen Edition with four performances from November 21-22, 2026. STEP INTO THE NEON-LIT LIMBO OF RIDE THE CYCLONE - the "edge-of-your-seat" modern cult classic musical sensation that turns a tragic accident into an electrifying celebration of the human spirit. The production is directed by Bri Fogleman.



Partnership with Hammonton Theater Lets Students Stage New Musical

Partnership with Hammonton Theater Lets Students Stage New Musical 'The Figuring'

(GALLOWAY, NJ) -- There are still some things to figure out about a new partnership between Stockton University and Hammonton's Eagle Theatre. But that's all by design. It's also part of a new show that made its debut November 12-15 on campus and will be performed at the Eagle on November 21, 2026.



Passage Theatre Company presents "Jitney" by August Wilson

Passage Theatre Company presents "Jitney" by August Wilson

(TRENTON, NJ) -- This holiday season, Trenton's only professional theatre company is staging the first-ever performance of an August Wilson play within the state capital. Passage Theatre Company will present August Wilson's Jitney, directed by Zuhairah McGill and starring Passage Theatre Executive Artistic Director Brishen Miller as Booster. The production runs from November 27 through December 20, 2026. The production is supported in-part by funding through the NJEDA's A.R.T. – Phase II Grant Program, Isles, and GoTrenton.



Centenary Stage Company presents Disney

Centenary Stage Company presents Disney's "Frozen: The Musical"

(HACKETTSTOWN, NJ) -- Centenary Stage Company presents Disney's Frozen: The Musical, this year's Family Holiday Spectacular, running November 27 through December 13, 2026 in the Sitnik Theatre of the Lackland Performing Arts Center. Based on the beloved Academy Award-winning Disney animated film, this musical features music and lyrics by Kristen Anderson-Lopez and Robert Lopez, with a book by Jennifer Lee.



Westfield Community Players present "Miracle on 34th Street - A Live Radio Play"

Westfield Community Players present "Miracle on 34th Street - A Live Radio Play"

(WESTFIELD, NJ) -- Westfield Community Players present Miracle on 34th Street - A Live Radio Play from November 27-29, 2026. Directed by Jose Rivera, this is adapted by Cass Cochrane and based on the novel by Valentine Davies and the 1947 screenplay by George Seaton.



Surflight Theatre presents Irving Berlin

Surflight Theatre presents Irving Berlin's "Holiday Inn"

(BEACH HAVEN, NJ) -- Surflight Theatre presents Irving Berlin's Holiday Inn from November 28 through December 20, 2026. The beloved film classic comes to the stage in a charming crowd-pleaser featuring one glorious Irving Berlin number after another, each celebrating a different festivity.



George Street Playhouse presents "2 Pianos 4 Hands"

George Street Playhouse presents "2 Pianos 4 Hands"

(NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ) -- George Street Playhouse presents 2 Pianos 4 Hands, written by Ted Dykstra ("The Expanse") & Richard Greenblatt (Letters from Lehrer), and directed by Tom Frey (Souvenir). 2 Pianos 4 Hands begins previews December 1, 2026, at the New Brunswick Performing Arts Center and is set to open December 4, for a run through December 20, 2026.



East Lynne Theater Co. presents "Fully Committed"

East Lynne Theater Co. presents "Fully Committed"

(CAPE MAY, NJ) -- East Lynne Theater Company closes its 2026 mainstage season with Becky Mode's hilarious and fast-paced, one-man comedy Fully Committed, directed by Mark David Boberick and starring Andrew Betz. The show will be performed at the Clemans Theater for the Arts at the Allen A.M.E. from December 3-20, 2026.



Spring Lake Theatre Company presents "Scrooge"

Spring Lake Theatre Company presents "Scrooge"

(SPRING LAKE, NJ) -- Spring Lake Theatre Company presents their annual production of Scrooge across three weekends from December 3-20, 2026.  One of the most beloved Christmas traditions follows the story of Ebenezer Scrooge as he gets visited by three spirits.